File talk:Flags of New Caledonia.svg

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Renaiming request

[edit]

I want to summarize the conflict:

For me, the original reason from User:LuisAngel01 to rename from File:Flags of New Caledonia.svg to File:Pre-IndependenceFlags of New Caledonia.svg (Affects others links; Criterion 10) was invalid as I can not find Criterion 10 on COM:FR. Quite the contrary, Criterium to decline #3 says If a filename in a local project conflicts with a filename at Commons, the file in the local project should be renamed. Renaming it at Commons would mean changing it in 500+ projects instead of just one.. So for me, the first rename of User:Marcus Cyron on 11. Aug. 2015 at 00:39:38‎ with the reason File renaming criterion #3: To correct obvious errors in file names, including misspelled proper nouns, incorrect dates, and misidentified objects or organisms was a violation of the rules and in my opinion the file can be renamed back to the original name. The reason to decline of User:Mich.kramer Name allready given for a picture does also not apply in this case as it is only the redirect to this file. --Capricorn4049 (talk) 16:17, 14 September 2015 (UTC)[reply]

Thanks Capricorn4049. I've added a couple points to the timeline above for clarity.
There's no objection from me for a discussion about a rename, but any move should be based upon policy and consensus. TDL (talk) 00:08, 15 September 2015 (UTC)[reply]